Monday, January 28, 2019
Justification for Torture
bedevilment is a scenario that dates back to the old presidential term ages. Is govern manpowert bedevil ever justified? This answer is weed be answered by this quote,Torturing the terrorist is unconstitutional? Probably. But millions of lives surely outweigh constitutionality (Levin 1). Who would not give up the lives of fellow citizens If the only option to solve the issue was excruciating an singular for his crimes? M either people would see the situation as a sacrifice for the better of the people. The lives of Americans should be the most important priority of a nation.Torture is justified as spacious it is for the safety of the people and not for the mere cause of violence. Torture is the considered to be a harmful mentally and physically to anyone. It is a actually well known method in the time of war. There induct been many cases where it used on children and women. The telephone circuit of torture can range from physical abuse to sexual abuse. Those atomic number 18 without a doubt an international crime. use torture on candid human being is completely out of the question. The use of torture in terms of pissing boarding on terrorist can be an separate(prenominal) matter.Torture without a doubt is a cruel treatment for an man-to-man but it must be a nation policy (Falbaum 15). salvage candid lives should be a governments priority in a check mark time bomb scenario. The scenario states, lets say an slayicer, got control of a terrorist planning an blow on hundreds of people. It is highly likely this terrorist pull up stakes be interrogated by other officials to obtain information somewhat the access. Torture should be an option if the individual refuses to give the data to save hundreds of lives.Falbaum also mentions that 9/11 attack could been prevented if the get together States had torture as part of their system. If the US policy was more(prenominal) strict at those times the terrorist would have feared their policy or would have captured their leader and gained details about the whereabouts of the attack. A poll establishs that majority of registered citizens opt harsh techniques that can keep America safe (Bauer 27). The society should withstand inhumane behaviors like torture if it is seen as last hope for innocent lives.Successful interrogations can keep America safe for the future. The world revolves most information and if your country is lacking information, terrorists can take advantage of the situation. Using torture on terrorists to gain information will benefit in prevention of future attacks on the country. Marc A. Thiessen goes into detail how many terrorists that have been interrogated provided them with time-tested information that ended up saving thousands of American lives. Thiessen cerebrates that terrorist suspects will let out if pressured in the right way (Thiessen 36).Some people may urge that torture does not provide the right detail because the victim will say anything to stop the deadly act. A statement said by the terrorist Abu Zubayah explains that captive terrorist tends to resist as long as they can, if they fail to do this they are minded(p) permission by their religious belief to regulate what they have known. The job of the interrogator is to safely help the terrorist do his indebtedness to Allah, so he then feels liberated to speak freely (Thiessen 40). It leads to show if the US practice and enhance their torture techniques it will lead to a safer nation.What techniques can be considered torture? Water-boarding is the act where the victim is drained water supply on his head to stimulate the pain of drowning. Water-boarding to Joseph Farah is not considered torture. He states that the technique is relatively safe with the right management. Not only that he argues that United State also practice this technique on their own soldiers as training (Farah 82). According to him while water-boarding is very abhorrent it is not as bad as cutti ng of a hand or anything gore.The impartiality is Water-boarding is very effective and most of the time the firmness are given in less than a minute. The success stories range from learning about cornerstones top plans. It is said that the terrorist agents resisted normal interrogations for hours and hours but gave into water-boarding sooner than the word can be said. This scenario can happen anywhere in the nation. Lets say an al-Qaida member was captured by the CIA and found whereabouts of bombs being placed around a city. They hire the top of the line negotiators to spoil the information.The real question save remains. Will they be able to make the terrorist member talk onwards its too late? Then again we could resort to the use of water-boarding and save their lives before it is too late. It is not like we have torn their limbs off to order to get the information. But a few seconds of dripping water on a prisoners face? Thats not torture to me (Feah 85). Some believe that t orture disregard true American standards. Patrick J. Buchanan gives a great insight about this issue. He states that torture is viable as long as it fit to save the American people.It is just like how murder is seen wrong yet you see soldiers and cops given the permission to kill as long as it fits the right scenario (Buchanan 55). Would a war hero that killed twenty men in order to rescue 2,000 citizens receive a death doom? Just because he murdered 20 men, no. He would be honored as a hero he so deserve to be. There are doctors that inflicts pain to many soldiers in the war study by cutting of parts of their body. This saves their life by preventing death by decay. These are one of the exceptions that torture should be given into.Take for utilization someones son or daughter was captivated by a terrorist group. champion of their remember was found, he would not spoil or hint any information by simple conversations. What will a parent would lack from the government to do? I t does not matter if they oppose torture or not, a parent would choose water-boarding compared to the death of their child. Torture is not to be taken lightly but should be considered an option if the situation arise. Torture should the last option if it ever to be used. It a very sensitive topic for many people.There are groups that strongly rejects torture in any situation and there are people that support torture if it leads to saving lives. Ultimately saving lives should be the priority of any government. If it result in agreeing to an harsh techniques like water-boarding to stop future 9/11 attacks, the majority will agree. It is very hard to come to a result about this specific topic because both sides can provide very good viewpoints. It will be one of those controversial topic that will go on for decades.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment